1986 Press Photo Fisherman, Pewuakee Lake, holds pike with slashes and gouges

What is lurking below the surface of peaceful Pewuakee Lake? What could have slashed and gouged the northern pike (left)? Some say it's a muskie. Ron Leys says it's an alligator.

Photo measures 8 x 10 inches. Photo is dated 09-21-1986.

.

Photo back: